WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.030 --> 00:00:02.350
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: few minutes to set up. Apologies.

2
00:00:03.370 --> 00:00:06.299
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: I hope, remote can hear us.

3
00:00:06.830 --> 00:00:09.299
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Yes, they confirmed they can hear its recording.

4
00:00:10.290 --> 00:00:11.990
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Can we start, please?

5
00:00:12.970 --> 00:00:13.830
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Okay.

6
00:00:14.330 --> 00:00:19.520
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, welcome, good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to this special colloquium.

7
00:00:19.680 --> 00:00:25.370
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Decoding the 2026 Nobel Prize in Physics. I forgot to close the door, so let me do that.

8
00:00:31.770 --> 00:00:33.999
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, let me begin.

9
00:00:35.040 --> 00:00:39.199
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: With a rather memorable quote, from our speaker.

10
00:00:39.450 --> 00:00:48.280
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Professor Subhi Sarkar, back in 2011, when the OPERA experiment appeared to suggest that neutrinos were traveling faster than light.

11
00:00:48.470 --> 00:01:00.759
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Subir was quoted in The Guardian as saying, if we do not have casuality, we are buggers. It is a wonderfully direct way to… of expressing the stakes in the fundamental physics.

12
00:01:01.350 --> 00:01:06.570
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: The apparent results threatened to overrun our understanding of the space, time, and cause and effect.

13
00:01:06.780 --> 00:01:08.210
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: As it turned out.

14
00:01:08.940 --> 00:01:19.710
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: The measurement was traced to instrumental problems, but the episode reminds us how extraordinary claims must withstand extraordinary scrutiny.

15
00:01:20.200 --> 00:01:23.839
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Today, we are… Returning to neutrinos.

16
00:01:24.700 --> 00:01:32.059
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But with a very different and much more successful story, the discovery of high-energy neutrinos arriving from the astrophysical sources.

17
00:01:32.260 --> 00:01:37.610
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: The 2026 Nobel Prize in Physics recognizes Francis Hazel.

18
00:01:38.210 --> 00:01:46.470
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: for his decisive contribution to the IceCube Neutron Observatory, and the discovery of high-energy neutrinos of astrophysical origin.

19
00:01:47.500 --> 00:01:55.009
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: At the South Pole, Scientists have transformed a cubic kilometer of Antarctic ice into a telescope

20
00:01:55.160 --> 00:01:58.129
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: For those elusive cosmic messengers.

21
00:01:58.380 --> 00:02:05.820
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Neutrinos can travel across billions of light years, passing through enormous amounts of matter, almost entirely unnoticed.

22
00:02:05.980 --> 00:02:10.329
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: While carrying information about some of the most extreme environments in the universe.

23
00:02:10.949 --> 00:02:14.489
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Yet, discovering these particles is only the beginning.

24
00:02:15.280 --> 00:02:16.580
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: What we can…

25
00:02:17.060 --> 00:02:36.779
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: What they can tell us about black holes, blazers, cosmic accelerators, why have some spectacular astrophysical events remained surprisingly elusive in the neutrinos, and what might this new window reveal about physics, about the standard model is the next step.

26
00:02:37.110 --> 00:02:43.449
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: To explore these questions, we have a particularly well-placed speaker. Professor Subhi Sakkar have been

27
00:02:43.560 --> 00:02:50.770
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: associated with the ICU collaboration since its inception in 2004, and have worked closely with Francis Helsen.

28
00:02:51.050 --> 00:02:57.509
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: He can, therefore, offer us a perspective that goes beyond explaining the achievement recognized by the Nobel Prize.

29
00:02:57.990 --> 00:03:05.809
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: He has been part of the scientific enterprise behind this remarkable experiment, and the questions that have driven it.

30
00:03:06.210 --> 00:03:10.890
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Professor Carr, is Emeritus Professor at the University of Oxford.

31
00:03:11.910 --> 00:03:20.320
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: or Oxford University, where he has been based at the Rodolf Pierre Center for Theatre Physics since 1990.

32
00:03:20.620 --> 00:03:23.820
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: He served as head of Oxford Particle Physics.

33
00:03:24.330 --> 00:03:33.469
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Theory Group from 2011 to 2019, and held the Neil Bohr's Professorship at the Neil Bohr Institute in Copenhagen from 2013 to 2018.

34
00:03:34.400 --> 00:03:39.559
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: His research spans astro-particle physics, cosmology, fundamental particle physics.

35
00:03:39.860 --> 00:03:44.289
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Bridging theoretical ideas with experimental efforts to understand the universe.

36
00:03:44.550 --> 00:03:51.979
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: His contributions have been recognized with the IUPAP Homey Harper Medal and the Prize in 2017.

37
00:03:52.430 --> 00:03:57.739
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: and the Bruno Rossi Prize in 2021, shared with the ISQ Collaboration.

38
00:03:58.160 --> 00:04:00.750
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: It is a great pleasure, thus.

39
00:04:00.970 --> 00:04:13.940
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: for me to welcome Professor Subhi Sarkhar, and he is also, the former member, of our lab here, and about years, and, so please welcome,

40
00:04:14.280 --> 00:04:16.420
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Please give him a big hands.

41
00:04:20.200 --> 00:04:21.999
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Given half my total…

42
00:04:30.090 --> 00:04:30.800
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: the boat?

43
00:04:40.190 --> 00:04:41.480
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Food prices, yeah?

44
00:04:43.000 --> 00:04:48.139
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And, what… The award has been given for.

45
00:04:48.490 --> 00:05:08.109
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: is, as it says here, for decisive contributions to the IceCube Neutrino Observatory and the discovery of high-energy neutrinos of astrophysical origin. So, detection of neutrinos from outside the Earth is not new. Kamiakande and Super Kamiakande and snow and so on did all that many years earlier.

46
00:05:08.250 --> 00:05:19.420
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But this is perhaps the first neutrino telescope. We can actually see where the neutrinos are coming from, and hope to identify the sources of these particles, which

47
00:05:19.760 --> 00:05:30.029
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Might be one of these pretty pictures up here, gamma ray bursts, active galactic nuclei spewing out relativistic jets of plasma.

48
00:05:30.350 --> 00:05:43.040
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: involving supermassive black holes. I mean, all the headline-grabbing things in astrophysics you can think of, they have been implicated with the possible origin of the highest energy particles in the universe.

49
00:05:43.100 --> 00:05:51.760
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And we have just started on the task of trying to decipher the story. This is by no means the end, it's just the beginning.

50
00:05:52.620 --> 00:05:56.500
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But, what I want to tell you today is, first of all.

51
00:05:56.710 --> 00:06:08.650
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Why am I giving the talk? I'm a theorist. Francis, by the way, is also a theorist, and that is what gives me the, you know, context to talk about an experiment.

52
00:06:08.840 --> 00:06:16.850
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: although he's a theorist, and it says so on his webpage, as you can see, I'm a theoretical… theoretician studying particle physics.

53
00:06:17.010 --> 00:06:21.119
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Based at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.

54
00:06:21.810 --> 00:06:26.970
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: He had this idea long back in the 80s, And he…

55
00:06:27.170 --> 00:06:34.680
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: managed to get 450 people counting today behind him to build this amazing detector, but it

56
00:06:35.090 --> 00:06:37.890
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: two and a half kilometers below the South Pole.

57
00:06:38.000 --> 00:06:39.220
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: to do this.

58
00:06:39.960 --> 00:06:43.080
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And, these people…

59
00:06:43.200 --> 00:06:58.719
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: are scientists of various kinds that are experimental physicists, some of whom are here, astrophysicists, engineers, technicians, and we meet twice a year, and it's actually a… given the kind of

60
00:06:59.000 --> 00:07:07.529
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: collaborations that you're used to. I should say that this collaboration is somewhat special, in the sense that it's actually very well-knit.

61
00:07:07.750 --> 00:07:13.730
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Everybody knows everybody, and in particular, young people get a chance to, you know.

62
00:07:13.950 --> 00:07:26.570
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: make a mark, to do their own thing, to suggest new analysis, to lead a paper. And in that respect, I think we have set new standards in the sociology of collaborations as well.

63
00:07:27.760 --> 00:07:36.560
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But given that I'm standing here giving this talk, I thought I would speak about a little bit of history relating to this lab.

64
00:07:36.680 --> 00:07:55.739
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, this is me, but at the time, we had less fancy boards, but, that's here in, what is it, 2000 and, 2000, so 26 years ago, when we were having the Christmas Theory meeting. So this was something that used to be organized by, the…

65
00:07:55.890 --> 00:07:58.520
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: the Rutherford Lab Theory Group.

66
00:07:58.870 --> 00:08:16.300
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: which had luminaries like Roger Phillips, and Wong Mo Chan, and Dick Roberts, some of you know these people, they've sadly all passed away. These were the younger postdocs, some not so young, that's Frank Close.

67
00:08:16.330 --> 00:08:31.450
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And these people were all here. We had a great time here, doing very good physics. Sadly, the same year that that picture was taken, they were… the group was disbanded, and

68
00:08:31.570 --> 00:08:50.300
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Well, that's how it goes. But I wanted to point out that at that time, in the entrance hall, there was a quotation from Newton about there are agents in nature able to, you know, mediate interactions between particles, and it is the job of experimental physicists to find them out.

69
00:08:50.440 --> 00:09:00.630
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And I wonder if it is still there, because that would be a, you know, a flashback to those times when this lab was actually… the theory group was one of the best known in the world.

70
00:09:02.150 --> 00:09:16.309
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Anyway, that's nostalgia. I just wanted to point out, the reason I put up this slide is because what I talked about, that was 26 years ago, was about the excitement in ultra-energy cosmic rays and neutrinos.

71
00:09:17.010 --> 00:09:22.740
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And that has taken some time to bear fruit, but bear fruit it has.

72
00:09:23.030 --> 00:09:26.060
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So let me also tell you how I got into this business.

73
00:09:26.640 --> 00:09:45.000
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, those of you who are experimentalists know that it takes a long time to build up relationships with people across the world to, you know, gain their trust, to build a working partnership, and that's what happened with the first spokesperson of IceCube, was this gentleman here, Perilla Fulz.

74
00:09:45.000 --> 00:09:57.189
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: from Stockholm, because he was the principal investigator, a spokesperson, of an experiment with the big European bubble chamber at CERN, in the so-called WS66 beam dump experiment.

75
00:09:57.260 --> 00:10:03.729
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And, I was interned in the theory group, but my wife, Mandy, she was working on BEPS.

76
00:10:03.830 --> 00:10:16.759
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And I realized that what they were doing was be sensitive to a wide variety of searches for new particles, which are then just being talked about. This is 1983 I'm talking about.

77
00:10:16.990 --> 00:10:32.959
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: like supersymmetric particles, heavy neutral leptons, milli charged particles, and so on. So I suggested that we should look for these things, and that was a very fruitful partnership. So when Perula became the first spokesperson of IceCube, he asked me to join.

78
00:10:33.830 --> 00:10:43.309
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Now, you might wonder, how does a theorist contribute to an experiment? This is also new. It has not been traditionally the case that theorists participate in experiments.

79
00:10:43.310 --> 00:11:01.520
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: At best, at CERN, they would go off and write a yellow book or something, and then, you know, as happened at LED, outlining all the theoretical issues and what measurements need to be made, and then experimentalists do it, right? But this is… IceCube is on less firm ground, theoretically.

80
00:11:01.520 --> 00:11:10.140
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: than the standard model was, at length. So, you do need to do things as you go along. So, just to give you a couple of examples.

81
00:11:10.700 --> 00:11:18.030
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: I realized that the first… the process for deep elastic scattering, by which we detect neutrinos at IceCube.

82
00:11:18.190 --> 00:11:23.599
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: That requires knowing the cross-sections at energies far higher than have been measured in the lab.

83
00:11:23.730 --> 00:11:37.369
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Even today, they have not been measured beyond a few hundred GeV. Very recently, at CERN, using the collider-made neutrinos, two experiments have detected them up to TEV energies, that's phaser and SNG.

84
00:11:37.520 --> 00:11:42.620
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But, there's a big gap to the energies that we are talking about.

85
00:11:42.890 --> 00:11:54.130
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: However, that cross-section can be theoretically calculated with some reliability by measuring the so-called pattern distribution functions in the nucleus.

86
00:11:54.210 --> 00:12:04.860
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And this is something that had been done very well at the Hera Collider at Hamburg in EP collisions, but for the purposes that we are talking about

87
00:12:05.010 --> 00:12:10.320
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: The charge doesn't matter, you can just take out the electromagnetic part and just look at the weak part.

88
00:12:10.630 --> 00:12:23.129
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And so we calculated these cross-sections, and that paper is still the basis of the event generator that is used by IceCube today for all analysis. It has also been adopted by KM3Net.

89
00:12:24.010 --> 00:12:40.599
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Another example was a collaboration with a student at Oxford working on LSCB, Rory Gould, and he was studying charmed hydroproduction, and it turns out that LSCB, because it looks quite forward in rapidity, is very well suited

90
00:12:40.600 --> 00:12:51.560
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: to provide us the data that we need to estimate the background of charmed mesons made in the atmosphere by cosmic rays, which generate neutrinos which can mimic

91
00:12:51.560 --> 00:13:02.660
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: with the heart spectrum, astrophysical neutrinos. Anyway, you get the idea. We wrote a number of papers which are all about predictions for the neutrino flux from various kinds of sources.

92
00:13:02.660 --> 00:13:12.240
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: predictions for what the interaction cross-sections, the inelasticity, and so forth should be, and that's how we make ourselves useful in IceCube.

93
00:13:12.920 --> 00:13:26.049
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But since I realize the audience here is kind of broad, let me start with a review of cosmic rays to highlight why we are talking again about cosmic rays. Sorry, I should stay close to the microphone.

94
00:13:26.050 --> 00:13:34.319
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: after so many, years. So, as you know, they were discovered over a century ago, and that is the…

95
00:13:34.360 --> 00:13:53.299
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: first experiment done to measure cosmic rays flown by Victor Hess on a balloon. So I actually had two of these. This is just evacuated chamber with two plates which are charged and repel each other, but if you put in some ionization in there, then the plates will come closer together.

96
00:13:53.440 --> 00:14:02.970
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And he found that the ionization actually increased as you went up, rather than decreasing, as you would expect if it was due to radioactivity.

97
00:14:03.090 --> 00:14:08.950
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So that was the discovery of cosmic rays, and Milliken actually called them cosmic rays.

98
00:14:09.060 --> 00:14:16.219
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And the first fundamental physics discovery that came out of them was when Paul Dirac, a few years later.

99
00:14:16.510 --> 00:14:23.559
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: said that his mathematical equation, relativistic equation for the electron, predicted that there should be a counterpart

100
00:14:23.690 --> 00:14:30.849
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Electron traveling backwards in time, effectively, which would look to us like a particle with the opposite charge to an electron.

101
00:14:31.000 --> 00:14:44.280
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And he himself didn't know what to make of it. He thought it might be the proton, but that didn't make sense. They have very different mass. But it took one picture by this guy, Carl Anderson, who was at Caltech.

102
00:14:44.520 --> 00:14:55.670
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Who did this beautiful experiment in the cloud chamber, where a particle enters, and as you see, loses energy in the sled plate, so you can see which direction it's going, and the curvature increases.

103
00:14:56.020 --> 00:15:04.710
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But the curve feature is in the wrong direction. It is curving as if it is a positively charged particle, an electron, from the ionization tray.

104
00:15:05.000 --> 00:15:22.549
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, that one picture suddenly doubled the number of particles in the universe. For every particle, now we know that there is an antiparticle. This was an amazing thing, and it was quite fitting that Anderson and, in fact, Victor Hess shared the Nobel Prize.

105
00:15:22.840 --> 00:15:35.040
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And of course, the gentleman, C.R. Wilson, who invented the cloud chamber, also got a prize, because the technique, the experimental method, is just as important as the theory or the actual discovery.

106
00:15:35.970 --> 00:15:44.460
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And similarly, the story goes, I'll go quickly through this, this must be familiar to most of you. Yukawa predicted that there should be a particle,

107
00:15:44.550 --> 00:16:00.720
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: which is the mediator of the strong force. And actually, it was Hume Bhawa who called it a mesotron, and people looked for it. Some people searched for it in nuclear emulsions exposed at altitude. Bhiva Cholderdi was the early pioneer in India.

108
00:16:00.720 --> 00:16:20.169
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But their technique wasn't good enough. Their emulsions were not… were too coarse. And it took the efforts of Cecil Powell at Bristol, who worked with the people who made the emulsions, the company, to develop plates which actually were good enough to show the track of a pion.

109
00:16:20.880 --> 00:16:35.660
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And in fact, our professor, Don Perkins at Oxford, told me that he actually had one of the first pione tracks exposed in a experiment that he did up in the Az around that time.

110
00:16:36.360 --> 00:16:45.340
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And then there was the discovery of the muon, which was a bit of a side distraction, because this was not the pion.

111
00:16:45.340 --> 00:16:56.700
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: It was actually a heavier version of the Electron, and you may know that Ravi famously said who ordered that, because they were sitting in a Chinese restaurant at the time.

112
00:16:57.070 --> 00:17:05.220
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And, Blackett, who developed the cloud chamber method further, also got a Nobel Prize. So, this was all great stuff.

113
00:17:05.220 --> 00:17:18.189
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But then you might ask, this was, like, 100 years ago, you know, why should we care? What has cosmic rays done for particle physics since then? Well, I'm going to make a bold claim that without cosmic trays, there would have been no LHC.

114
00:17:18.660 --> 00:17:23.900
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And that's because, you may recall that when the LSC was proposed, people were saying that it would

115
00:17:23.960 --> 00:17:35.999
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: destroy the Earth. It would create black holes, or, you know, quark nuggets, or something of the other, and they would destroy us. And it actually took the observation by this panel that was convened at the time.

116
00:17:36.000 --> 00:17:47.669
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: that cosmic rays have been doing such collisions for billions of years, and nothing has happened. So, you know, that should be convincing to anybody without having to

117
00:17:47.670 --> 00:17:57.369
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: do a careful calculation of what is the chance that the LSC will actually produce a black hole. This is much simpler. And so you know where that went.

118
00:17:57.370 --> 00:18:08.480
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: It led to the discovery of the Higgs boson, and that, of course, has been the greatest advance, I think, in particle physics in the last century.

119
00:18:08.540 --> 00:18:18.349
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Because it was not even something that had to be there, it is just a mathematical trick which nature seems to have exploited, for reasons that we still don't really understand.

120
00:18:19.400 --> 00:18:35.389
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So here we are today, and nothing more has been discovered beyond the Higgs, and a lot of particle physicists are in despair because they think this is the end, and, you know, there are any number of people on social media who know nothing about it who will tell you that this is the end. But they have forgotten

121
00:18:35.820 --> 00:18:37.859
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: The cost for the high energy produce.

122
00:18:38.120 --> 00:18:43.739
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: That's where all this began, 100 years earlier. So that's what we're going to talk about today.

123
00:18:44.850 --> 00:18:54.089
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Now, this is a plot of the radiation that we received from the universe. If you had a perfect detector, which measured at all wavelengths.

124
00:18:54.110 --> 00:19:06.329
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: and you measured the amount of energy that is being received per decade of, you know, wavelength or energy up here, then you would see this. And most of the energy, as you might expect, is in the cosmic microwave background.

125
00:19:06.330 --> 00:19:16.939
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: from the Big Bang. That's our cosmological origin. But, in… after the World War, radio astronomy developed, and we found radio sources and a radio background.

126
00:19:16.970 --> 00:19:26.600
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And then we went beyond optical into ultraviolet and X-rays. This requires flying detectors above the Earth's atmosphere, which would otherwise absorb it.

127
00:19:27.090 --> 00:19:37.409
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But there is a limit. You can't go beyond a certain point, because although we have gamma-ray detectors on the ground, which can look up to, you know, tens of T…

128
00:19:37.640 --> 00:19:44.050
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: There is a barrier which is created by the fact that there are all these microwave photons in the way.

129
00:19:44.060 --> 00:20:03.410
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: and infrared photons, and a high-energy photon can actually create a pair by hitting a lower energy photon, and that threshold is around 10 TEV, so you can't actually see the deep universe with these ground-based atmospheric current telescopes beyond that energy.

130
00:20:03.920 --> 00:20:07.960
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Now, cosmic rays are also stopped by the same photons.

131
00:20:07.980 --> 00:20:25.029
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But that takes a little more energy, because in the nest frame of the proton, the photon has to look like a 100 LV gamma ray in order to excite the delta 1232 resonance, and that means the proton has to have a gamma factor of 10 to the 11

132
00:20:25.360 --> 00:20:36.210
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: 10 to the 11 GeVV, in other words. So at that point, cosmic blades will also start getting attenuated. But we can look out a few hundred meoparsecs with cosmic blades of that energy.

133
00:20:37.200 --> 00:20:53.739
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: However, and that's the neutrinos that are shown here in green, the universe is transferred into neutrinos at all energies, all the way back to a redshift of 10 to the 12th, at a time when the universe was hot enough that the weak interactions came in Eclipia.

134
00:20:54.380 --> 00:21:05.729
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Now, how do we detect these neutrinos? Well, here is a nice schematic to indicate how you go about doing that. So, you… I'm only talking about high-energy neutrinos, more than 10G.

135
00:21:05.920 --> 00:21:08.189
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So the cosmic rays hit

136
00:21:08.490 --> 00:21:23.629
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: molecules in the atmosphere and create an air shower, and most of that air shower that's going through us right now would be muons, which have reached the ground. Most of the other stuff has decayed. There's also an electromagnetic component, and the neutronodes just pass through us.

137
00:21:24.010 --> 00:21:36.920
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: The muons can be detected by covering the surface with detectors of various kinds, or deep underground, you can instrument water and ice, as we have done at Ice Cube, and… or you can do it in the Mediterranean.

138
00:21:37.470 --> 00:21:47.569
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And, if you look right at the air shower, along the air shower, you'll be able to see Charentov radiation from the particles, which are traveling faster than light in the atmosphere.

139
00:21:47.710 --> 00:21:53.820
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And those are telescopes like HES, Veritas, Magic in La Palma, and so on.

140
00:21:54.520 --> 00:22:02.129
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: We can also look at the fluorescence radiation excited in the molecules by the high-energy particles in the shower.

141
00:22:02.310 --> 00:22:07.150
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And if it is a very dark night, which it is in Argentina about

142
00:22:07.370 --> 00:22:16.820
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: 10% of the nights. You can see the track of the cosmic day in the atmosphere if you have a Schmidt camera looking at a very wide field of view.

143
00:22:17.710 --> 00:22:19.109
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And,

144
00:22:19.300 --> 00:22:33.039
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: The other thing you can do is to look for particles coming from down, you know, going up through the Earth, because the muons would be absorbed by the Earth, but neutrinos can come through. So the initial idea was to look through the Earth to find the neutrinos.

145
00:22:33.090 --> 00:22:40.019
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: In fact, it turned out that actually that was too hard. We, in fact, found the neutrinos coming down, as I'll show you.

146
00:22:41.790 --> 00:22:48.960
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Today, the effort is mainly on developing radio detection, because these showers

147
00:22:48.990 --> 00:22:52.890
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: There is a charge separation that also emits a radio pulse.

148
00:22:52.910 --> 00:23:11.830
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And neutrinos also create showers at high enough energies which will give the same kind of pulse. And if you can detect that and discriminate from the background, then you have a very cheap way of covering a very large area. So that's what the action is currently. We have experiments right now running in Greenland and in the Antarctic ice.

149
00:23:11.830 --> 00:23:16.720
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Trying to detect neutrino showers with, with radio.

150
00:23:18.000 --> 00:23:27.880
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, the cosmic rays that I showed you earlier, creating showers, they, as you know, extend over a huge energy range, and people show this plot.

151
00:23:27.880 --> 00:23:38.770
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: to indicate that the energies go from all the way from a GEV up to about a million times the energy in the NHCB, about 10 to the 11 GEV.

152
00:23:38.800 --> 00:23:45.729
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And, the spectrum is a falling power law. In fact, I multiplied it by E squared, even so it is falling quite steeply.

153
00:23:45.780 --> 00:23:55.300
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, the flux is decreasing very, very rapidly, so by the time you get to about this energy, there's roughly one particle per square kilometer per century.

154
00:23:55.420 --> 00:24:10.540
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So you need to build very big detectors to measure these things at all. But at lower energies, you can fly satellite detectors, you can measure them in detail, you can see that they have actually got not just protons, but all sorts of heavy elements.

155
00:24:10.540 --> 00:24:19.250
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: They have a percent-level electrons, they have about one part in 100,000 positrons, and a much smaller fraction of antiprotons.

156
00:24:19.250 --> 00:24:31.840
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: These are made by secondary interactions, we think. There are no primary sources, although the AMS experiment has recently claimed to have seen antihelium nuclei, which, if true, would mean something pretty exciting.

157
00:24:32.400 --> 00:24:52.269
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And the evil suspects for where they come from are the remnants of supernovae, exploding stars, active galactic nuclei, which are supermassive black holes at the centers of galaxies, which are feeding, which are accreting matter, and by some means shooting them out as jets of radio-hystic plasma.

158
00:24:52.650 --> 00:24:57.620
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And both of these we have now identified as cosmic resources.

159
00:24:57.650 --> 00:25:13.069
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Gamma-ray bursts are events where an object as heavy as our sun is converted in a few seconds into pure energy, photons. We still haven't seen any evidence of cosmic deacceleration there, but they're likely suspects.

160
00:25:13.150 --> 00:25:19.380
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And the extended depths of radio galaxies, etc, etc. So lots of question marks in the game. But…

161
00:25:19.400 --> 00:25:34.210
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Wherever these cosmic rays are being accelerated, and you can see that the extent to energies well beyond what we can do on terrestrial labs. So there is a fundamental particle physics interest in determining these

162
00:25:34.320 --> 00:25:43.420
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Measuring these particles, because we can also do fundamental physics with them, if you understand something about their properties.

163
00:25:43.930 --> 00:25:56.499
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Now, these neutrinos will be produced when these particles are being accelerated or are propagating, simply through the interactions of the nucleonic component with the background matter or radiation.

164
00:25:57.120 --> 00:26:09.530
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And effectively, we'll always end up getting, as in the atmosphere, two muon neutrinos and one electron neutrino, so that would be the expected ratio. But of course, neutrinos oscillate amongst each other.

165
00:26:09.530 --> 00:26:22.140
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And the oscillations would average out if you go over very long distances, as we are now doing in the observations made by IceCube. So you would expect to see roughly equal numbers of this.

166
00:26:22.190 --> 00:26:32.099
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: in, you know, in detail, it's like 0.98 times 0.97196. You can calculate it, you just solve the equation for the propagation.

167
00:26:32.240 --> 00:26:40.449
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And that is, in fact, very important, because if anything disturbs those oscillations, then this ratio changed.

168
00:26:40.660 --> 00:26:58.049
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So we now have a handle by measuring the flux ratios at IceCube on the propagation of neutrinos over potentially megabassic distances, and we can then be sensitive to very subtle effects, which are hypothetical, but well motivated.

169
00:26:58.050 --> 00:27:04.560
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: For example, that spacetime itself might have a structure at the Planck scale which decoheres neutron oscillations.

170
00:27:04.870 --> 00:27:12.870
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So this is something that you can speculate about, but if you want to test it experimentally, here is something you can actually measure in a

171
00:27:13.160 --> 00:27:15.880
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Detector, which can test that idea.

172
00:27:16.030 --> 00:27:18.339
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: The director, however, has to be very big.

173
00:27:19.080 --> 00:27:36.280
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But that detector has been now built, and with that, we have detected these atmospheric neutrinos, which I mentioned, and we have also detected an astrophysical flux, which looks flat here, because I've multiplied the flux by E squared, so the spectrum is actually falling as 1 over E squared.

174
00:27:36.400 --> 00:27:44.389
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And we have also seen emission from our galaxy, just like we see it in radio, X-rays, gamma rays, we also now see it in neutrinos.

175
00:27:45.030 --> 00:28:02.609
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: There is also an expected flux of neutrinos due to those cosmic interactions that I mentioned on the microwave background. They're called cosmogenic neutrinos. That has not yet been detected. That is our next goal, but the flux here is so low that we'll need an even bigger detector than the one we currently have to do that.

176
00:28:04.020 --> 00:28:15.699
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, let me start by, you know, this is, like, I'm not going to go through all the physics of IceCube, but I don't want to, bore you just with facts. I think all of us

177
00:28:15.820 --> 00:28:35.579
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: love physics, you love doing it, so, you know, it's nice to remind ourselves that sometimes physics can be fun. So this is the Pierre Rogi Observatory in the Pampa Maria in Argentina, and that's one of the tanks of several thousand such tanks dotted over 3,000 square kilometers, right?

178
00:28:35.590 --> 00:28:55.560
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: There are 1,600 such detectors, each of those dots, right? And they basically are a tank full of very pure water, which is viewed by three photomodiplasts, which look for the Cherenkov radiation emitted by charged particles going through them, and when they see something, they fall back to base with that thing there.

179
00:28:55.650 --> 00:28:58.269
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And it's, you know, we had to raise this

180
00:28:58.280 --> 00:29:16.939
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: meter and a half from the ground, because the cows on the pampa otherwise would chew it up. And that turned out to be very interesting, that we now have a little solid angle towards the ground, so we can see whether there are any showers coming out of the ground, as might happen due to tau neutrinos entering over the horizon.

181
00:29:17.010 --> 00:29:26.969
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, you know, in experimental physics, it's always nice to find something that was not in your LOI or MOU or whatever, and which just turns out to be a bonus.

182
00:29:27.850 --> 00:29:46.500
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Surrounding this array of detectors, there are four hills on which we have these Schmidt telescopes that I mentioned that look for the fluorescence radiation from the showers. And we, in fact, usually look at all this data from our base, which is in the nearby town of Malarju.

183
00:29:47.320 --> 00:29:52.659
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So that's Luis Anchildi, my colleague, and I, installing some electronics on one of them.

184
00:29:53.200 --> 00:30:06.410
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And that's a air shower coming in on Auger, and you can see that the footprint, by the time it hits the ground covers many, many square kilometers, and can have as many as 10 to the 10, 10 to the 11 particles.

185
00:30:06.970 --> 00:30:26.290
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And this is one that came in when I was on shift, and it's very exciting that this one was caught by all four of the fluorescence telescopes which tracked it, and therefore you know its energy pretty well, because the atmosphere is like a calorimeter. And this energy is about a million times higher than the, you know, the beams in the LHC.

186
00:30:26.550 --> 00:30:31.399
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, you better believe it, there are particles of that energy being made by nature.

187
00:30:31.410 --> 00:30:48.349
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Right? And it's still a mystery as to how nature does it, because the most simple consideration, which was given by Michael Hillas, who was at Leeds, was that, well, whatever they are, they have to at least contain these particles, so the Lamar radius should be smaller than the size.

188
00:30:48.350 --> 00:31:00.679
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So if you plot the magnetic field versus the size of the object, then you create a diagonal line, which would correspond to an energy of, that kind of energy. This is for 10 times higher, 10 to the 20 eV proton.

189
00:31:00.880 --> 00:31:08.690
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And it'll be smaller for an ion nucleus, because what really matters is the rigidity, the energy per momentum per unit charge.

190
00:31:09.550 --> 00:31:27.369
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And you can see that most of the usual suspects don't get anywhere near that. The only things that could possibly exhilarate such particles would be gamma-ray bursts, because you don't really know the magnetic field, it could be high, or radio galaxy jets, because they're very big, even though the field is not very strong.

191
00:31:27.670 --> 00:31:32.140
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And maybe there are other things that we don't know about that would populate that track.

192
00:31:32.310 --> 00:31:43.219
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But what's for sure is that if I wanted to create a particle of that energy using LHC technology, it would have to have the diameter of the orbit of Mercury.

193
00:31:43.400 --> 00:31:52.549
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: That's not happening anytime soon, so that's why you have to look at the sky to identify these particles and try to make sense of them.

194
00:31:52.790 --> 00:32:05.470
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And the nephinos come about, as I said, when such particles are being accelerated, that we know this happens because they would be interacting with ambient matter or radiation, and it is very easy to make a simple argument

195
00:32:05.580 --> 00:32:10.700
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Based on the known cosmic reflux of how many neutrinos you expect.

196
00:32:10.710 --> 00:32:27.680
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: That just depends on some efficiency factor, so the theory part is just to do with calculating what fraction of the energy would go into neutrinos, and if you make a reasonable estimate for that, you come up with a number for about 10 to the minus 8 per square centimeter per second per steroidian.

197
00:32:27.680 --> 00:32:33.499
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: of, so this is directly normalized to the cosmic reflux. These neutrinos should be there.

198
00:32:34.550 --> 00:32:49.069
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Now, where might they be coming from? So here is a cartoon of an active galactic nucleus. So, you don't actually see the black hole, it is shrouded in matter, and there is accretion disk around it, which also emits radiation in the

199
00:32:49.070 --> 00:32:57.569
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Made in infrared, but the jet comes out along the axis of rotation, and this is all speculation as to what might be happening in the jet.

200
00:32:57.990 --> 00:33:12.529
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Right, so all we know is that we have seen TED gamma rays from that jet. So, gamma rays have, of that energy. To create them, you have to have either inverse content scattering or the pion decay.

201
00:33:12.590 --> 00:33:22.599
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And if it was pione, then you are getting hot, because then you would be able to implicate cosmic pre-acceleration, but we have so far no direct evidence of that.

202
00:33:23.380 --> 00:33:35.110
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Now, people look for correlations of these events with known objects. So, for example, Centaurus A is a nearby active galaxy, and there are actually two Auger events very close to it.

203
00:33:35.170 --> 00:33:49.330
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But we don't really know how cosmic rays propagate, because there are magnetic fields in the interlact medium. We don't know their strength. In the galaxy, there are magnetic fields. It's not very well known, especially away from the galaxy.

204
00:33:49.330 --> 00:34:01.480
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And so, you can't ever pin it, right? And this is why neutrinos are so important, because if you have an object like that shooting out stuff, then only the photons and the neutrinos will come directly to you.

205
00:34:01.680 --> 00:34:14.249
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And the gammas are easy to detect, but gammas can be absorbed close to the central engine by the decretion disk I mentioned, whereas neutrinos would let you look straight down into the heart of the matter.

206
00:34:15.239 --> 00:34:27.139
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And that's why you need to build air shower arrays and also neutrino detectors, combined with Damerell telescopes and other wavelengths that you can get access to.

207
00:34:27.600 --> 00:34:41.389
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But a simple estimate will show you that if I take the cross-section for neutrinos that we know already, and ask how big a detector do I need, made of, you know, say, some cheap material like

208
00:34:41.389 --> 00:34:48.479
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: In water or ice, because there are naturally occurring large volumes of these materials.

209
00:34:48.580 --> 00:34:53.419
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Then, a simple calculation shows you that you need about a kilometer cube detector.

210
00:34:53.980 --> 00:34:59.499
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And this is the calculation that Francis and John learned, who is at Hawaii.

211
00:34:59.540 --> 00:35:15.149
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: did back in 1988. They presented it at a conference in Poland, and they had this kind of fanciful sketch with a bit of little flag on top of what a detector like that might look like, and they claimed it would be cost-effective.

212
00:35:15.700 --> 00:35:17.480
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Now,

213
00:35:17.810 --> 00:35:32.459
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: for two theorists to make a proposal like that, which, by the way, had also been suggested in the Russian literature earlier, that's fine, and the numbers work out, but then the question is, how do you actually make it happen?

214
00:35:32.940 --> 00:35:45.269
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And that was Francis's, talent, because if you now ask, can we actually detect the kind of sources I've been showing you in neutrinos? Well, here is Sandaurus A, which I mentioned.

215
00:35:45.270 --> 00:35:55.979
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And this is the same object seen in different wavelengths, and you can see how different it looks. So in the optical, it just looks like a huge, blurry mess of light, because

216
00:35:56.010 --> 00:36:09.140
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: everything is shrouded in dust. If you look in infrared, then it looks, actually, you can see the disk. So here is Spitzer image of the same object. You can even see something falling into the central black hole there.

217
00:36:10.280 --> 00:36:27.889
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: If you look in radio, then you see those jets being shot out that are emitting synchrotron radiation, and in fact, that synchrotron radiation carries on into 50-60 KB energies. So those are… those jets are actually synchrotron radiation and X-rays.

218
00:36:27.970 --> 00:36:41.979
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, how many neutrinos would you expect from that object, right? Well, this calculation was actually run by Francis and his postdoc at the time, and the answer is you would get about, at best, one event per square kilometer per year.

219
00:36:42.680 --> 00:36:51.009
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, now you're seeing the challenges that come with this exciting physics. But that hasn't stopped physicists, because we are…

220
00:36:51.250 --> 00:37:02.089
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: I guess, overly ambitious. And, it started off the coast of Hawaii with Duman, which John Lernard was trying to motivate, but that never worked.

221
00:37:02.290 --> 00:37:07.660
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And then there was Nestor off the coast of the Peloponnese in Greece, near Pilos.

222
00:37:07.770 --> 00:37:12.239
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: That actually did count neons, but didn't get further than that.

223
00:37:12.280 --> 00:37:22.040
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And, the next thing that happened was a detector called Antares, that's just off the coast of Toulon in, in the Med.

224
00:37:22.040 --> 00:37:36.709
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And they had the support of the French Navy to try to sync this detector, which has been quite successful in measuring neutron oscillations. It was too small to actually see astrophysical neutrinos. And then IceCube.

225
00:37:36.890 --> 00:37:52.770
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And there are also long-standing activity going on in Lake Baikal in Siberia, which is both a water and ice detector, because it freezes over in the winter, and then you can walk out on it and lure detectors into the water.

226
00:37:52.770 --> 00:38:09.550
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And of course, meanwhile, there have been these very successful detectors in Kamiakande. SuperKame and now HyperKamikande is being built, but they are much lower energy. They're around tens of MeV than the TEV to PEV energies we are talking about.

227
00:38:09.900 --> 00:38:21.240
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And there is more in the pipeline. These are the radio detection techniques that I mentioned earlier, Ariana, Aura, or the Dartik RNOGs in Greenland. The G stands for Greenland.

228
00:38:21.240 --> 00:38:30.060
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And IceCube Gen 2 will also employ radio. And then there are detectors called Anita, which are… fly around the South Pole on a balloon.

229
00:38:30.060 --> 00:38:38.420
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And have seen some strange events, which we still don't know, how to explain. But the successor mission will be PUA,

230
00:38:38.540 --> 00:38:47.820
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And then there are experiments proposed to detect the air showers, like Grand in China, Trinity, which will be in Uta somewhere.

231
00:38:48.290 --> 00:39:08.089
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And, just to show you how beautiful the locations are of this experiment, to try to persuade you to join these collaborations, this is Lake Baikal, so our, one of our colleagues on IceCube, from, Daisy Zoyton, he has worked on Baikal for a long time, Kristian Spiel.

232
00:39:08.190 --> 00:39:26.300
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And this is P1, which is a Pacific 1, which has been started by a colleague Elisa Resconi at Munich, and the directors have actually been built by our undergraduate students, and she's getting a professional telecommunications company to lower them into the water.

233
00:39:26.430 --> 00:39:38.750
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Another one of our ISQ postdocs went back to the Shanghai TDLE Institute, and she's in charge of Trident, which will cover most of the South China Sea, as you see there. And,

234
00:39:38.910 --> 00:39:51.599
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: There is, in fact, competition in China. Another Chen Kao, who led, leads LASO, a particularly experiment, he wants to build an even bigger detector in light bicycle.

235
00:39:52.070 --> 00:40:04.410
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And this is CAM3Net, which you have heard of, which is a, combines, well, is a successor to Antares, really, but it has ORCA and ARCA, which is the big detector off the coast of Sicily.

236
00:40:05.010 --> 00:40:14.959
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, there's a lot going on. But, let me come quickly to IceCube, because I see I'm running out of time. We did start 10 minutes after… okay, so I'll take it.

237
00:40:15.140 --> 00:40:30.069
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, IceTube is not actually at the geographic South Pole, it's slightly displaced from it, and the South Pole Station is on the other side of the plane's landing. So, as you see here, they have propuls, turboprops, landing there on skis.

238
00:40:30.070 --> 00:40:38.870
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: You have to come from McMurdo, and McMurdo is about 8 hours to fly from Christchurch in New Zealand, which is the last stop. And that's the South Pole Station.

239
00:40:38.870 --> 00:40:55.749
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And there is actually a pole marker, and it says north, north, north, north, north, north, all the way around. So the people at the pole, they divert themselves by having a run around it, which they call a round-the-world race. And,

240
00:40:55.750 --> 00:41:05.599
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Here we have the actual south… the ice tube detector is buried deep underground, but that's just what we call the counting house, which has all the computers.

241
00:41:05.600 --> 00:41:09.239
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And that's what's featured in all the press shots of Ice Cube.

242
00:41:09.320 --> 00:41:27.139
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: You can't see that from at the back, but this was taken in July, and it says something like minus 90. So the warmest it gets is about minus 40, which fortuitously is the same temperature in centigrade and Fahrenheit. So, when our American politics say minus 40, we know what they mean.

243
00:41:27.900 --> 00:41:30.179
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And, of course, you see beautiful Lord Rudhu.

244
00:41:30.810 --> 00:41:44.549
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And this is the timeline of IceCube. Like I said, first proposed in 88, then they tried building a detector called Amanda, which, at a shallow depth, just down to about 800 meters, and it didn't work.

245
00:41:44.660 --> 00:42:02.580
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: It did detect muons, but no neutrinos. And undeterred by this, I took… was proposed by Francis, who then managed to persuade the National Science Foundation to shell out nearly $250 million for it. And that was finally completed in 2011.

246
00:42:02.600 --> 00:42:05.110
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And then there was a,

247
00:42:05.600 --> 00:42:12.100
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Tense period of a couple of years, when we are wondering why we are not seeing neutrinos.

248
00:42:12.300 --> 00:42:24.939
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And then, in 2013, we did detect it, and also nutrient oscillations. So IceCube actually makes competitive measurements of nutrient oscillations with all the long baseline experiments on Earth.

249
00:42:25.860 --> 00:42:33.510
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And in 2018, we detected the first source, which was a AGN pointing straight towards us, we call it a blazer.

250
00:42:33.880 --> 00:42:40.909
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And, then we also see some exotica, like in 2021, we saw an on-shell production of a W.

251
00:42:40.970 --> 00:42:57.089
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: by a neutrino scattering of an electron. This had been proposed by Shelley Glashau back in 1960 or something, when we thought the W mass was 3 GeV, so it's actually 30 times heavier, so it was 100 times more difficult to find this.

252
00:42:57.420 --> 00:43:08.130
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And then we found a second source, and now we have 3 other candidate sources, and then we saw the Milky Way, and the story continues. So let me very quickly tell you about this detector.

253
00:43:08.360 --> 00:43:21.030
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, basically, there are 86 strings going down between 1.5 to 2.5 kilometers in the ice, and each string carries 60 of these optical modules, which are about this big.

254
00:43:21.170 --> 00:43:33.780
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And, they are strung, like this on a long thing spaced by about 17 meters, and the strings themselves are a 125 meters apart.

255
00:43:33.880 --> 00:43:43.470
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And so there are a total of 5160 doms, and I'm happy to say that thanks to these guys who actually designed the doms at Berkeley.

256
00:43:43.470 --> 00:43:58.030
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So Dave Nygren, some of you might know, he was the guy who invented the time projection chamber, and he also turned his talents to designing this DOM, where the signal is digitized right there, and then sent back to the surface.

257
00:43:58.030 --> 00:44:03.970
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: as a digital signal, which means I can actually run IceCube from my laptop right here, from anywhere in the world.

258
00:44:04.350 --> 00:44:09.759
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And that was a real breakthrough, because Amanda had used analog signals, and that doesn't work too well.

259
00:44:10.040 --> 00:44:13.440
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: This… each of these things takes about 3.5 watts.

260
00:44:13.760 --> 00:44:16.000
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But there are about 5,000 of them.

261
00:44:16.450 --> 00:44:17.859
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And,

262
00:44:18.370 --> 00:44:31.729
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: We have some strings closer together in the very middle. This was led by Sweden, by Perula Full, and that is to lower the energy threshold to about 10 GeV, so you can start measuring nutrient oscillations, and in fact.

263
00:44:31.730 --> 00:44:38.949
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: More recently, we have done an upgrade where 5 more strings were sunk, so we can lower the threshold to maybe one.

264
00:44:39.400 --> 00:44:53.940
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And Tom Geyser, who sadly is also no longer with us, was in charge of the surface array, which are basically tanks, just like you saw in Oje, but these ones are full of ice rather than water, and they detect the air shot on the surface.

265
00:44:54.290 --> 00:45:09.639
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And so, basically, that signal is digitized down to nanosecond precision, which is important, because a nanosecond is about a foot in travel time, and these strings are a hundred meters apart of order.

266
00:45:09.640 --> 00:45:14.520
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, what we required is that when a DOM gets a signal.

267
00:45:14.570 --> 00:45:26.930
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: A whole bunch of them, within a microsecond, have to fire together, only then we send a signal to the surface. That way, you cut out most of the noise, right? And that brilliant idea was due to the Berkeley.

268
00:45:27.690 --> 00:45:36.590
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And, that signal then is processed by all those computers in the counting house and transmitted via satellites back to home base.

269
00:45:36.660 --> 00:45:51.200
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And, this is to show you, these are some details, but I think people here might appreciate them. So this is the typical waveforms from a event, and using now, you know, various

270
00:45:51.200 --> 00:46:01.869
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: kinds of neural networks, we can actually determine in a statistically prayable way what direction the event was going in, even when it is a real blob, just from the timing.

271
00:46:02.010 --> 00:46:09.860
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: When it's a muon track, it's easy, but when it's electron or tau, it's not so easy. And so, we have been making use of machine learning right from the beginning.

272
00:46:10.920 --> 00:46:16.130
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And this is a… Animation which will show you how those holes are drip.

273
00:46:16.130 --> 00:46:35.530
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, the first thing you need is a 5 megawatt hot water drill, and you need the drillers. These are the kind of people who put out fires in oil wells, right? All pirly guys who wear their baseball caps back to front, and know what they're doing. Another reason I think IceQ works is that we don't let all the

274
00:46:35.530 --> 00:46:43.300
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Hard jobs be done by physicists, who will make a complete mess of it. Get professionals, they do it right, right? They're paid for it.

275
00:46:43.550 --> 00:46:53.020
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But of course, you need physicists on hand to tell them what to do, and to design it in the first place. So here is a animation, if it works, of,

276
00:46:53.420 --> 00:46:57.110
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: of the drill, yes.

277
00:46:57.210 --> 00:47:06.719
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Of the drill, which first penetrates to the surface permafrost, we call it the fern, and then, once it has cleared the channel.

278
00:47:06.720 --> 00:47:20.300
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Then you bring in the hot water, and the hot water drill then starts going down and down and down and down, all the way down to about 2.5 kilometers. So this is the hole that results, it's about this wide.

279
00:47:20.300 --> 00:47:34.769
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And that takes about 3 days to freeze up. And before it does so, you take these strings that have been pre-prepared and tested and so on, and lower them down, and then they're frozen into the ice. And I'm happy to say that of those

280
00:47:34.770 --> 00:47:44.760
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: thousands of DOMs, only 5 are not working. That is, 98.2% are still working, right? After 15 to 20 years, which is impressive.

281
00:47:45.090 --> 00:47:50.529
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: If you did that experiment in the Mediterranean, about a third of your DOMs would be gone by.

282
00:47:51.400 --> 00:48:10.799
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So this was our last season where actually the event was taken on a traverse, rather than on C-130 planes. So this experiment only works because you have the support of the US Armed Forces, because they maintain the Southport base for strategic reasons, so that we can piggyback on that. And you can see that

283
00:48:10.950 --> 00:48:16.030
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: This is when the physicists join in and, you know, help to do that full work.

284
00:48:16.270 --> 00:48:32.949
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And this is the collaboration. It is not very large by the standards of certain collaborations, but the UK is… so Oxford is the only member in the UK, because I have to say, my experimental colleagues at Oxford didn't think IceQ would ever work, so they didn't join us.

285
00:48:33.010 --> 00:48:43.079
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: I asked them to. I bet they're kicking themselves now, and I hope they are. And, the idea is simply that once you have instrumented the ice.

286
00:48:43.100 --> 00:48:53.009
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: If neutrino creates a charge particle, the charged particle moves faster than the speed of light, and that cone is about 40 degrees. It's set by the refractive index of ice.

287
00:48:53.010 --> 00:49:06.919
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And it's a very blue light, because the thing goes as 1 by lambda square, and you can see this ghostly blue light with all these detectors, and as I said, you use likelihood optimization to determine the tracks and so forth.

288
00:49:07.460 --> 00:49:16.599
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And given that there is very little transverse momentum in this, you have good alignment of the charge left on in the incoming neutrino, so you can do astronomy.

289
00:49:17.160 --> 00:49:35.209
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And here is a simulation of a 326 TV neutrino coming in, and you can see the muon, so the neutrino has already interacted outside in the rock, and the muon goes through. And keep in mind that this thing is a kilometer across. That's a pretty big event.

290
00:49:35.350 --> 00:49:40.190
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And the time and the number of photons is indicated as shown there.

291
00:49:40.780 --> 00:49:51.519
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, that kind of event is easy to see. Much harder, but more numerous, are cascade events, which are basically blobs due to electron neutrinos.

292
00:49:51.520 --> 00:50:07.539
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: In the case of a tau, you know, you'd expect two blocks, because first one, you create a tau lepton, and then the tau lepton, at that energy, travels hundreds of meters before decay, and so you get a second block. We have about six, seven candidates for these, but, still getting there.

293
00:50:07.970 --> 00:50:18.279
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Now, the advantage of this kind of events is that we know the total energy pretty well, but you don't know the direction, and the reverse is the true for the tracks.

294
00:50:18.450 --> 00:50:26.530
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: We have to estimate the energy for which many clever ideas have been put up, you know, from the stochasticity of the energy loss, you can estimate the energy.

295
00:50:27.400 --> 00:50:34.859
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And, by doing all this, finally in 2013, as I said, we detected two events.

296
00:50:34.860 --> 00:50:53.270
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: which are almost filled the detector, so it was evident in hindsight that we could have actually detected them with just two strings. We didn't need so many. And we started naming them after characters in Sesame Street, but rapidly ran out of names, because there aren't that many Sesame Street characters.

297
00:50:53.270 --> 00:51:01.860
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And this was our first real breakthrough, because it was recognized as something that nobody had done before.

298
00:51:01.900 --> 00:51:05.900
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And let me now just show you very quickly,

299
00:51:06.020 --> 00:51:13.600
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: How challenging it is, because experimentalists should know, or will appreciate, what the challenge is.

300
00:51:13.680 --> 00:51:28.339
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So what this is showing you is that the total number of events as a function of the zenith angle, so this is looking up from the South Pole, so looking down from where you are now, and this is looking in the other hemisphere.

301
00:51:28.460 --> 00:51:43.210
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And you see this huge background of mostly atmospheric muons and atmospheric neutrinos made by those cosmic clay air showers in the atmosphere. And you see here, this is about 10 orders of… 9 orders of magnitude.

302
00:51:43.530 --> 00:51:44.390
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Right?

303
00:51:44.550 --> 00:51:51.470
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: That is what you're up against if you want to detect this flux of astrophysical neutrinos, which is this orange bit down here.

304
00:51:52.410 --> 00:51:54.360
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: How did you manage to do this?

305
00:51:54.620 --> 00:51:58.969
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Well, the idea, as I said, was to look through the Earth, but that wasn't working.

306
00:51:59.090 --> 00:52:09.099
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And then a postdoc had a happy idea. He says, look, if you are prepared to sacrifice out a third of a director and use it as a veto.

307
00:52:09.100 --> 00:52:24.769
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: and demand that the neutrino interaction should happen in that outer third. Then we can get rid of this background, because these neutrinos that are produced in this travel almost together with the muons. They're very collimated, very little repeated.

308
00:52:25.310 --> 00:52:26.590
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So,

309
00:52:26.670 --> 00:52:40.960
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: best way to show that is to indicate what the event distribution is. So, the picture you should have in mind is that this atmospheric neutrinos are being made all over the Earth, and they're going all the way through.

310
00:52:40.960 --> 00:52:48.150
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: the muons are coming mainly from the sky above you, because they can't come up through the Earth. So there is an asymmetry…

311
00:52:48.590 --> 00:52:57.269
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And this is a plot of the total events, and I should just indicate that this is one, and that is million, okay? So it's a log scale.

312
00:52:57.280 --> 00:53:09.550
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And this is the total number of events in a two-dimensional plot of the total charge, the number of photoelectrons in all the DOMs, versus the number of photoelectrons just in that outer veto layer.

313
00:53:09.870 --> 00:53:27.319
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, we can now, in this plot, reject everything except the ones here, which is the signal region, when we have a cut of less than 3 photoelectrons in the signal layer, versus a total signal of more than 6 hours.

314
00:53:27.700 --> 00:53:41.009
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And it is by doing this that we manage to isolate this astrophysical flux from that huge background of muons and atmospheric neutrinos, but it does mean throwing away most of our data.

315
00:53:41.620 --> 00:53:55.100
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Once we knew that those neutrons were there, then we can actually use the upcoming muons from the other side, with that as the null hypothesis, and it turned out that they confirmed it at high significance.

316
00:53:55.210 --> 00:54:00.750
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But in any case, this was a detection of extraterrestrial neutrinos at more than 5 sigma.

317
00:54:01.910 --> 00:54:17.490
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And then it turns out that the neutrinos that we are seeing, when plotted on the same plot as the cosmic rays that I was showing you earlier, and the photons, are actually comparable in energy density, as you might expect. So it's like the entire universe is like a huge calorimeter.

318
00:54:17.520 --> 00:54:36.150
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Where the interactions of these cosmic disk create photons and create neutrinos, and the relationships between these three is illustrated here, and that is the basis of what's called multi-messenger astronomy, which I'll just spend two minutes on, because it's so interesting, you should… I want to say very quickly something about it.

319
00:54:36.470 --> 00:54:42.410
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, as I said already, most of the astronomy that we have ever done was using photons.

320
00:54:42.610 --> 00:54:51.539
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And that's, of course, been very rewarding. And cosmic rays has also been very rewarding, but that wasn't astronomy, because they don't point back to their sources.

321
00:54:51.960 --> 00:55:09.610
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And neutrinos, initially, of course, we identified some sources simply because from the timing, so Supernova 87A, we only saw anti-electron neutrinos. The distribution is isotropic, so they don't point back. But, of course, from the timing, you knew that they came from that object.

322
00:55:10.400 --> 00:55:28.179
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But the diffuse astrophysical flux is, of course, all over the sky, but the extragalactic source, we actually knew where it came from, and I'll show you that in a second. And now we also have gravitational waves from black hole mergers. So what we did, as soon as we started seeing these events, was to set up an alert system

323
00:55:28.180 --> 00:55:34.400
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: on which my then-postdoc, Mahmal Ramiz at Copenhagen, Was instrumental in setting up.

324
00:55:34.480 --> 00:55:35.420
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And…

325
00:55:35.800 --> 00:55:51.020
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: This alert system basically says whether an event is likely to be atmospheric or not, with some confidence. So a gold means we are pretty sure it's astrophysical, and such events are typically coming close to the horizon.

326
00:55:51.490 --> 00:56:03.310
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And this has been going on since 2016, and it paid off when we detected this event. This was in 2018. We saw a neutrino coming from that direction.

327
00:56:03.310 --> 00:56:14.220
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: with an energy of 290 TEV, but the error box was very large, because the pointing is only about half a degree, right? That's very poor in astronomy.

328
00:56:14.460 --> 00:56:28.919
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: However, because we put out an alert, we heard immediately from the Fermi satellite people and from ground-based atmospheric Thereank telescopes that they had seen a flaring blazer from that direction with a much tighter error box.

329
00:56:29.430 --> 00:56:42.070
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, when you put those things together, you can say that that was the source of the neutrino, and the multi-messenger campaign established that that source is a direct shift of about a third.

330
00:56:43.420 --> 00:57:01.789
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And when we looked in our archival data in the same direction, we saw that that source had been firing neutrinos at us all the time, but which we had not, of course, been separate… able to separate from the background. But putting it all together, we are now fairly certain, at almost 5 sigma, that that is a source of

331
00:57:01.790 --> 00:57:11.240
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: neutrinos, and that would then be also the first cosmic ray accelerator, which can push you up to, you know, 1000T via P.

332
00:57:12.510 --> 00:57:25.870
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But this activity is continuing, and unfortunately, not every postulated source actually gives us neutrinos, so this is the biggest gamma ray burst of all time, called VOT for greatest of all time.

333
00:57:25.940 --> 00:57:26.715
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And…

334
00:57:27.530 --> 00:57:45.149
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: This has the highest energy photon ever observed by that Lasso experiment in Tibet I mentioned, but we haven't seen anything in neutrinos from it, and that is actually quite disappointing. It might be that the neutrinos are being beamed in a very, very forward direction, that's what Alvaro di Rula claims.

335
00:57:45.150 --> 00:57:51.289
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: In which case, it is possible that we missed it, because our pointing is not that good. But…

336
00:57:51.440 --> 00:58:06.250
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Eventually, we'll have good pointing, and we'll be able to see the sources in much the same way that we are currently able to see the Milky Way and neutrinos, along with seeing it in gamma rays and optical and so on.

337
00:58:06.250 --> 00:58:20.210
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But this, of course, relies on the fact that the neutrinos are coming from the same cosmic interactions that give us the high-energy gamma rays that are mapped by Fermi and other telescopes. So we've got to combine all the data together to actually get something out.

338
00:58:20.210 --> 00:58:28.399
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And the other big target is, of course, the sources of gravitational waves. These black hole mergers… black hole mergers by themselves should not

339
00:58:28.400 --> 00:58:37.600
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: are not likely to give us neutrinos. But when they saw this neutron star merger, then you would have expected neutrinos from that.

340
00:58:37.600 --> 00:58:49.579
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So this is just showing that for black hole mergers, with just two detectors, you can't even triangulate it very well on the sky. You get this whole strip, and neither Antares nor IceCube saw any neutrinos.

341
00:58:49.780 --> 00:59:01.429
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But we did expect to see neutrinos from this object, which was seen by every detector at that dock. But, you know, we didn't see anything in neutrinos, which is, you know, it's kind of disappointing.

342
00:59:01.430 --> 00:59:17.260
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: It just means that there is more to that source than meets the eye. Again, pointing might be indicated, or maybe we've got the physics of it wrong. There's nothing like building an experiment to find out what the truth is, rather than relying on theoretical models, and I say that as a theorist.

343
00:59:18.460 --> 00:59:34.800
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, I'm coming to the close, I just wanted to show you this amazing Glashauer event, which was, it says here, Glashauer 1959. He was actually at the Needsboro Institute when he wrote this paper, pointing out that you could have an event.

344
00:59:34.800 --> 00:59:42.339
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: where the neutrino… electron neutrino scatters of an electron and creates a W. So this was the first detection of

345
00:59:42.340 --> 00:59:58.249
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: both anti-electron neutrino and of the Glashore resonance. And my contribution is to show that the deep inelastic scattering cross-section, which is shown here, is not sufficiently high to account for what you see in this event.

346
00:59:58.570 --> 01:00:07.919
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And the cross-section calculation that we did has actually been verified in a very surprising way by looking at neutrino absorption in the Earth.

347
01:00:07.920 --> 01:00:20.730
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Because the Earth at high enough energies does absorb neutrinos, and that is what you would expect on the basis of the standard model of the Earth, for how much attenuation should there be when you look at different directions within the Earth.

348
01:00:20.730 --> 01:00:25.500
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And to cut a long story short, when we do all this, we find that

349
01:00:26.010 --> 01:00:44.049
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: the cross-section here measured by laboratory experiments, which had been not measured at any higher energies, is actually quite consistent with what we had predicted on the basis of those quatern distribution functions measured at AR. So that was very satisfying. And in fact, some

350
01:00:44.050 --> 01:01:02.409
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: people have opportunistically turned it around to say we can now do tomography of the Earth, so then you can publish a paper in Nature, because they get excited by that. And you can see that going forward, if you had a sufficiently big detector, then we would be able to go up to energies of the order of 10 to the 10, 10 to the 11 GE,

351
01:01:02.410 --> 01:01:20.030
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And there you might expect to see the effects of new physics, which, speculative, you know, the idea that there could be objects called phalerons in the standard model, or a color glass condensate in QCD, they would give you predictions different from the standard model so far, the productivity standard model.

352
01:01:20.030 --> 01:01:23.150
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And for this, you have to build an even bigger detector.

353
01:01:23.150 --> 01:01:45.299
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And that is what I want to come to at my closing slide. Before that, I just… advertisement for how, if you measure neutron oscillations over long distances very carefully, you'd be sensitive to any of these things, you know, to variations, violations of the Q-valence principle, or Lawrence invariance, or decoherence, etc, etc.

354
01:01:45.300 --> 01:01:48.410
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And currently, the status of the art is the following.

355
01:01:48.410 --> 01:01:59.159
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: If I look at the fraction of tau neutrinos, muon neutrinos, and electron neutrinos in our data, it's a… the error spike bar is this one here, the red.

356
01:01:59.160 --> 01:02:09.720
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: If you can get it down to about here, then you'd start discriminating between different hypotheses. So that is a very exciting prospect for doing new physics with IceCube in the coming decade.

357
01:02:10.020 --> 01:02:23.770
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But our publicity department creates pictures like this to show the world that we not only look for standard nephinos, we also do glaciology. We have at least four papers in the Journal of Glaciology.

358
01:02:23.770 --> 01:02:35.119
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Earth tomography I just mentioned. Oh, something very interesting, not on this plot, is that we find that our muon towns are a very direct measure of the temperature in the upper troposphere.

359
01:02:35.180 --> 01:02:52.319
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Which is exactly what climate modelers want, and have not had… ever had access to, in order to calibrate their models. And, maybe we'll get our funding from the climate science people, right? They never would have imagined that we could do this, but anyway.

360
01:02:52.320 --> 01:03:07.600
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So, this is the future. We have to think big. So, there is IceCube, and the proposal is to build a detector which is a lot bigger, and with a radio array on top, as I mentioned, in order to make it cheaper and affordable, and the idea is that

361
01:03:07.600 --> 01:03:21.680
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: We have just had the upgrade, and this is IceCube. The next thing is to go to the in-ice detector, and then the Gen 2 radio detector on top. And this will not cost any more than IceCube originally did, which was, as I said, about

362
01:03:21.680 --> 01:03:23.590
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: $270 million.

363
01:03:23.590 --> 01:03:46.820
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But if you think of it in sort of, you know, more manageable terms, it is 20 pence per ton of director. That's cheap, right? You can have your own ton for 20 pea. And the alert system that I mentioned earlier is now in full swing. There are multi-messenger astronomy has become a big thing. Every director in the world sends out alerts, receives them.

364
01:03:46.830 --> 01:03:58.260
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And that brings me to my summary, which I already have covered, I think, that bit about detecting sources. I've talked about multi-messenger astronomy.

365
01:03:58.380 --> 01:04:11.140
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: I've talked about measuring the neutrino cross-section at energies far beyond what can be done in laboratory experiments, and also effects on neutrino oscillations, which might be proof of new physics.

366
01:04:11.870 --> 01:04:14.259
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And so, in conclusion.

367
01:04:15.150 --> 01:04:31.179
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: To probe this cosmic energy frontier, you have to think in terms of big detectors. The particles are there, but they're not under our control, and there are a lot of things about them that we don't know, so the usual uncertainties of cosmic physics are definitely there.

368
01:04:31.180 --> 01:04:39.280
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But then, if you compare IceCube to a traditional collider detector, I think it's actually doing pretty well in terms of banks per buck.

369
01:04:40.040 --> 01:04:41.050
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So…

370
01:04:41.400 --> 01:04:50.000
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: In closing, I should quote someone, Marcel Proust, who spent most of his life in a darkened room because he had serious asthma and he couldn't go out.

371
01:04:50.220 --> 01:04:51.770
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And he said.

372
01:04:51.960 --> 01:05:10.649
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: The real voyage of discovery consists not in seeking new lands, but seeing with new eyes. And I think IceCube is a perfect example of that. And we also fulfilled one very important role, which I have not mentioned earlier, which is holding up the Earth. So I'll leave you with this. Thank you.

373
01:05:16.300 --> 01:05:18.860
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Thank you. Questions?

374
01:05:20.110 --> 01:05:21.130
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Probably.

375
01:05:27.080 --> 01:05:42.050
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: That was a great talk, actually. Just a question about your involvement in going down to Antarctica. Have you been there? No, and neither has Francis. Because, like I said, this experiment is run by professionals.

376
01:05:42.050 --> 01:05:59.339
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: They don't want random physicists who are not particularly useful hanging around there. But Francis tells me that if Gen 2 is funded, then he'll find it a way… find a way to… for us theorists to go down there and post for pictures, because that's really all you can do.

377
01:05:59.370 --> 01:06:00.240
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Perfect.

378
01:06:01.300 --> 01:06:11.509
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: I've been to Christchurch, but as I said, from there, it's another, day's journey. So you have to actually find 5 weeks, 6 weeks in your life which are free.

379
01:06:11.850 --> 01:06:23.809
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: takes a week to get down there, a week to come back, and the weather might be bad, so you can't just go to the South Pole like that. You might have to wait for a week, and once you're there, they can't just fly you out, because you've got tired.

380
01:06:23.830 --> 01:06:43.649
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So… and I've never had 6 weeks free in my life all these years. Fantastic, Dr. Subway. I didn't quite understand the difficulty in finding the direction in which these particles are coming from. I thought, since you have really long detectors, you could actually

381
01:06:43.760 --> 01:06:57.080
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Maybe you said it, maybe I didn't quite grasp it. You could time this, right? We do do the timing, but the point is that the electron neutrinos and tau neutrinos create… each neutrino creates its own charge lefto.

382
01:06:57.250 --> 01:06:59.460
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: The muon neutrino creates a muon.

383
01:06:59.580 --> 01:07:13.749
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Muon is a minimum ionizing product. It can go through the whole detector, you know, without stopping. That's very easy to track, right? But the electron, you should know, the electron loses energy much more quickly, and creates a kind of a spherical block.

384
01:07:14.080 --> 01:07:24.809
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: There, the time is crucial, and we do, in fact, determine the time, but the direction, we can't tell into better than a few degrees. So that's actually not good enough for astronomy.

385
01:07:25.050 --> 01:07:32.889
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Even if half a degree is pushing it. Astronomers laugh when we tell them we've got half a degree resolution, that, you know, they talk about seconds of arm.

386
01:07:33.310 --> 01:07:39.579
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But still, it is good enough to identify the first source. In that respect, we are doing…

387
01:07:45.290 --> 01:07:48.270
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Any questions from Zoom, please feel free to unmute.

388
01:07:52.440 --> 01:08:03.530
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: I just, recall the last, topic about, space-time, fluctuations. Yes. So this is extremely interesting, because everybody's really after

389
01:08:03.560 --> 01:08:23.319
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: the holy grail of quantum gravity. Right. So, I mean, I don't really fully appreciate how in neutrino oscillations would actually give you a signal on the quantum fluctuations. Right, so you can think of it in two ways. Either you might want to have a kind of a physical picture of what might be happening at the plant scale.

390
01:08:23.470 --> 01:08:26.609
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And a memorable one was given by John Wheeler.

391
01:08:26.790 --> 01:08:46.690
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: He said you could think of spacetime at that scale as a mainstream of, you know, black holes appearing and disappearing, and in that process, if a neutrino were passing by, and it would fall in and then be evaporate, there's information lost in the effective theory. Not in the full theory, but in the low energy that you are at compared to the black scale.

392
01:08:46.760 --> 01:09:05.029
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And that means that, you know, normally you would write a neutrino oscillation as some Hamiltonian operating on some vector gives you the final state that you observe. So that gets turned into something called a dollar matrix. So there is a part that contains the loss of information. The evolution is not immediately.

393
01:09:05.740 --> 01:09:20.860
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And you can parameterize that mathematically by something called the Lindblad formalism, so, which is like a… you're interacting with the thermal parts. So you have to have some kind of a phenomenological model for what modern gravity looks like, because you don't have any fundamental theory of it.

394
01:09:21.060 --> 01:09:25.199
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Another approach would be to just write down an effective theory, a fill theory.

395
01:09:25.359 --> 01:09:39.109
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But with high-dimensional non-normalizable objects. And all we can say is that quantum gravity involves gravity, gravity involves Newton's constant, Newton's constant has dimensions of 1 over mass squared.

396
01:09:39.319 --> 01:09:55.730
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So it'll be some dimension 6 operator that captures quantum gravity. And, so you can just write it down and try to determine what the coefficient of that is, and that's what we're doing in these experiments. So, basically, without knowing anything at all about the physics.

397
01:09:55.890 --> 01:10:01.980
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: We can still put constraints on the effective picture of what quantum gravity might be.

398
01:10:02.250 --> 01:10:10.180
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: By simply asking whether an observable that we have, namely the ratio of electron neutrinos to muon neutrinos to tau neutrinos.

399
01:10:10.400 --> 01:10:15.099
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Is exactly what you expect for oscillations in vacuum, or differs from?

400
01:10:15.350 --> 01:10:17.199
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: That's basically the story.

401
01:10:19.990 --> 01:10:20.820
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Yep.

402
01:10:29.050 --> 01:10:31.579
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Thank you for the wonderful talk.

403
01:10:31.740 --> 01:10:45.259
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: I just had one question. So, from the sources that you talked about, it seems like they were all quite, massive sources, active collecting nuclei and stuff like that. So I was quite curious if,

404
01:10:45.840 --> 01:10:51.459
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Is, is there, like, a smallest object you think you could study with IceCube?

405
01:10:52.110 --> 01:11:00.230
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Well, that was shown in that Hillas plot I indicated. So, if you plot the size of a source versus the magnetic field in it.

406
01:11:00.900 --> 01:11:07.429
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Then the… the requirement is that the source should be able to contain the highest energy particle.

407
01:11:07.660 --> 01:11:19.250
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: that we're thinking of, right? So if I see a 300TV neutrino, the parent particle of that has to be at least 10 times higher in energy, right? So 3PE. Then I ask.

408
01:11:19.370 --> 01:11:27.110
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: If I have a source of a certain size, a compact object, then what is the magnetic field that would be required to even contain that particle?

409
01:11:27.330 --> 01:11:41.369
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And now we know there's a limit to the magnetic field strength. You can't go much above 10 to the 13, 10 to the 14 gauss, because the vacuum would start breaking down, right? So, all these considerations enter into that plot that I showed, which indicate that

410
01:11:41.400 --> 01:11:47.399
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: The most compact objects we can think of which might be making these particles would be gamma-ray bursts.

411
01:11:48.330 --> 01:11:55.870
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But as I said, we have disappointingly not seen a single neutrino from a gamma Reis. And, that means, well.

412
01:11:56.000 --> 01:12:05.030
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: I look at it positively, that means you have got the physics of the Americas wrong, and we'll have to revise it when we finally see something not there.

413
01:12:06.610 --> 01:12:07.680
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Okay.

414
01:12:07.970 --> 01:12:08.680
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Okay.

415
01:12:11.190 --> 01:12:22.789
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Thank you very much for that extremely nice talk. So, just on your last point about future experiments… Yes. So, apart from Gen 2, which I assume you would like to see go ahead.

416
01:12:23.120 --> 01:12:29.450
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Which of the other… experiment that we talked about, do you think has the most promise? Well…

417
01:12:30.170 --> 01:12:34.199
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Lake Baikol has been going for the longest of all experiments.

418
01:12:34.370 --> 01:12:45.649
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But, as usual, although they were the pioneers, they haven't actually been able to, you know, make it work as successfully as IceCube has been because of the lack of resources, etc.

419
01:12:45.810 --> 01:12:51.789
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: But they have studied, they are, you know, they have studied the ice there very, very carefully over decades.

420
01:12:52.030 --> 01:13:05.490
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And, so, my personal bet is, well, this I just learned 2 months ago. I was in Beijing, and at dinner with this guy, Zhen Cao, who is the PI of Lasso, which is an experiment in Tibet.

421
01:13:05.670 --> 01:13:18.289
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: built against the odds, and very, very successful, right? And he just said casually to me, well, I want to build this detector called… the acronym is HUNT, which stands for Huge…

422
01:13:18.410 --> 01:13:28.779
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: underwater neutrino telescope. So, yeah, I want to build Hunt, and it'll be, I don't know, 35 kilometer cube, or some ridiculous figure like that.

423
01:13:29.370 --> 01:13:39.509
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: So normally, of course, one would dismiss such statements out of hand, but maybe these guys, you know, they won't say that unless they mean it.

424
01:13:39.800 --> 01:13:50.950
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: They've already delivered two impossible projects, so why not? So I… my money is on a next thing being a big underground… underwater telescope like that.

425
01:13:51.330 --> 01:13:56.109
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Because, IceCube, even Gen 2 will be only, only 8 kilometer cube.

426
01:13:56.580 --> 01:13:59.509
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: And we really would like something a bit bigger again.

427
01:14:01.470 --> 01:14:03.080
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: Thanks. Okay.

428
01:14:03.920 --> 01:14:12.349
STFC-RAL-Lecture (Pickavance) Theatre  R222: If there are no other questions, I would like to request everybody to please join speaker for refreshments and coffee afterwards, and let's thank Speaker. Thank you.

